[gmd3d]

Star Trek TMP is perhaps my favourite Trek Movie if I base it on the amount of times I have watched it over the others.... it suffered for a story and a ending during the making and the crew lacked the familiarity of the old series.

Star Trek 5, suffered from the same thing and was closer to the old series than most which I think Shatner wanted to do. but again the story did not live up to to
it for a Movie.

Star Trek 2, 4 and 6 where the best in the sense of been closer to the original show.

Shatner I would also agree is no where cheesy .. the Death of Spock and the catch in the voice over the torpedo casing holding Spock body and the already mentioned
David death in Star Trek 3....

Star Trek 2 and the death of Spock was the only film I ever cried and I think that was in no small part to Shatner´s performance and Nimoy´s too.